Introduction
Do you ever stop mid-sentence, wondering whether to say “They helped each other” or “They helped one another“? You are not alone! This is one of the most common questions ESL learners ask, and the good news is that the answer is simpler than you think. In this guide, we will break down the rules, show you real examples, and give you plenty of practice so you can use both phrases with confidence.
What Are “Each Other” and “One Another”?
Each other and one another are reciprocal pronouns. A reciprocal pronoun is a word that shows a two-way action — meaning person A does something to person B, and person B does the same thing back to person A. For example, in the sentence “Anna and Maria hugged each other,” Anna hugged Maria and Maria hugged Anna. The action goes in both directions.
These two phrases are used when the subject of the sentence is plural (two or more people or things) and the action is mutual. Think of them as the “mirror” pronouns of English — whatever one person does, the other does too.
Rules for Using “Each Other” vs “One Another”
- Traditional rule: Use each other for two people or things, and one another for three or more. Example: “The two sisters called each other every day.” / “The five teammates encouraged one another.”
- Modern usage rule: In everyday English, most native speakers use each other and one another interchangeably. Both are grammatically correct in modern usage, so do not worry too much about the number rule in casual conversation.
- Formality rule: One another often sounds slightly more formal or literary. You will see it more in writing, speeches, and formal contexts.
- Plural subject rule: Both phrases require a plural subject. You cannot say “She and each other talked” — the subject must act as a group, like “They talked to each other.”
- No possessive confusion: The possessive forms are each other’s and one another’s. Example: “They borrowed each other’s books.”
- Not a subject: These pronouns cannot be the subject of a sentence. Say “They know each other,” not “Each other knows them.”
- Verb agreement: The verb agrees with the plural subject, not with the reciprocal pronoun. Example: “The students help one another.”
How to Use Them
Follow these simple steps to choose and place the correct reciprocal pronoun:
- Check your subject. Is it plural (two or more)? If yes, you can use a reciprocal pronoun. If no, you cannot.
- Identify the mutual action. Is the action going both ways? “They love each other” works because the feeling is mutual. “They love pizza” does not need a reciprocal pronoun.
- Choose your pronoun. For two people, each other is the safest choice. For three or more, you may use one another, especially in formal writing. In casual English, either works.
- Place it after the verb or preposition. Example: “They smiled at each other.” / “We wrote to one another.”
- Add ‘s for possession. Example: “The neighbours borrowed each other’s tools.”
Examples in Sentences
- The two brothers looked at each other and laughed.
- My best friend and I call each other every weekend.
- The members of the book club send one another recommendations.
- All the students congratulated one another after the exam.
- The couple gave each other a gift on their anniversary.
- The five colleagues respect one another’s opinions.
- We should always help each other in difficult times.
- The children shared each other’s toys happily.
- The two teams competed against each other for the trophy.
- The volunteers encouraged one another during the long day.
- My cousins and I write to one another during the holidays.
- The dogs chased each other around the garden.
- The committee members disagreed with one another at first.
- Good friends trust each other completely.
Common Mistakes
Watch out for these frequent errors:
- Mistake 1: Using a singular subject.
❌ Maria and each other went shopping.
✅ Maria and her friend went shopping with each other. - Mistake 2: Using a reciprocal pronoun as the subject.
❌ Each other helped them.
✅ They helped each other. - Mistake 3: Forgetting the possessive form.
❌ They borrowed each other books.
✅ They borrowed each other’s books. - Mistake 4: Using it with a non-mutual action.
❌ The teacher and the students know each other the answer.
✅ The teacher and the students looked at each other. - Mistake 5: Wrong verb agreement.
❌ The players helps one another.
✅ The players help one another.
Quick Summary
- Each other and one another are reciprocal pronouns showing mutual action.
- Traditional rule: each other = two; one another = three or more.
- Modern usage: both are often interchangeable in everyday English.
- One another tends to sound more formal.
- Both need a plural subject and cannot act as the subject themselves.
- Possessive forms: each other’s and one another’s.
- The verb agrees with the plural subject, not the pronoun.
Practice Exercises
Fill in the blanks with each other, one another, each other’s, or one another’s.
- The two puppies chased ______ around the park.
- The six committee members respect ______ ideas.
- My sister and I share ______ clothes all the time.
- The teammates encouraged ______ before the big match.
- The couple wrote ______ love letters every month.
Answers:
- each other
- one another’s (or each other’s — both accepted)
- each other’s
- one another (or each other — both accepted)
- each other
Conclusion
Using each other and one another correctly is a small grammar detail that makes a big difference in how natural your English sounds. Remember the traditional number rule, keep the modern flexibility in mind, and watch out for the common mistakes we covered. With a little practice, these reciprocal pronouns will become second nature to you.
FAQ
Is it wrong to use “each other” for more than two people?
No, it is not wrong. The traditional rule says to use each other for two and one another for three or more, but modern English accepts both for any number. Most native speakers use them interchangeably in everyday speech, so you will not be misunderstood either way.
Can “each other” and “one another” be used as the subject of a sentence?
No. These are reciprocal pronouns, not subject pronouns. They must follow a verb or preposition, and the sentence needs a separate plural subject. For example, say “They respect each other,” not “Each other respects them.”
What is the possessive form of these pronouns?
The possessive forms are each other’s and one another’s. You add an apostrophe before the “s.” Example: “The friends borrowed each other’s notes.” This is important because leaving out the apostrophe changes the meaning and creates a grammar error.
Do “each other” and “one another” work with verbs that are not mutual?
No. These pronouns only work when the action goes both ways. For example, “They love each other” is correct because love is mutual. But you cannot say “They ate each other lunch” — eating is not a reciprocal action, and the sentence would be confusing and incorrect. Always check that the action is truly mutual before using a reciprocal pronoun.
